blog

Te Kete o Karaitiana Taiuru (Blog)

hobsons pledge

Image of Māori women used in racist adverts

Aukaha News story of a Māori women Ellen Tamati was woken my her mokopuna today to hear that her image of her face and moko kauae has been used in racist billboards advertising anti Māori wards. A campaign by Hobson’s Pledge. The media clip of the woman is here https://www.facebook.com/share/v/19LKSEc1f8/

my mana

Hours later, there was a public statement from Hobson’s Pledge:

We are aware of a video circulating online involving one of our Māori Wards campaign billboards, which features a stock image of a woman who has expressed distress at seeing her photo used.

The image was legally purchased through a reputable stock photography provider, and all rights to use it in public-facing materials were secured. However, upon seeing the video and understanding the impact on this individual, we have asked the billboard company to remove the advertisement immediately.

While the intent of the campaign was to promote an important conversation about democratic fairness and equal voting rights for all New Zealanders, we are saddened to see that this billboard has caused personal upset. That was never our intention.

We believe in having respectful and constructive conversations about Māori Wards. We hold the view that race-based electoral divisions are unnecessary and undermine equal suffrage, particularly when many Māori candidates are already successfully elected through general seats at both the local and national level.

We will be reaching out privately to the individual featured to ensure she is okay and to let her know her image is publicly available on stock image platforms. Regardless of the positive message we were promoting, we do not want anyone to feel distressed by our materials.
Thank you to everyone who continues to engage thoughtfully on this important issue.
If we look at the facts. Ellen Tamati’s image of her face was uploaded to a photo sharing web site called ShutterStock. It was uploaded by a Rafael Ben-Ari (his contact details), an international independent content creator and filmmaker specializing in documentary photojournalism and travel photography. It is highly likely that Rafael has without permission or with deceit used Ellen’s photo and uploaded it to ShutterStock as a royalty free image. His web site is full of images of Indigenous Peoples.
ShutterStock have an online form for Copyright breaches here.
This issue is not new with several public Māori faces often who have had their image stolen and appropriated.
To my knowledge, if someone takes a photograph of you, the photographer owns the copyright unless you commissioned the photographer and some other variations. There are likely moral rights in the Copyright Act to consider and the the Privacy Act is also likely to be another piece of legislation.
It would be interesting to know how the dynamics of a moko being used in the photo are considered in law.
If you want to take action, I would suggest contacting Rafael Ben-Ari online and ensure that you are polite and make your comments public on his social media so that potential clients will not use his business. The world needs to be aware of his actions and the harm he is causing.
Update: At 12.20pm today, it appears as though the image has been taken down from ShutterStock. I am also told by several people that the billboards were removed quickly around Tauranga and other places.

DISCLAIMER: This post is the personal opinion of Dr Karaitiana Taiuru and is not reflective of the opinions of any organisation that Dr Karaitiana Taiuru is a member of or associates with, unless explicitly stated otherwise.

Archive